Short answer: goods you hold on memo are not your inventory. Under US GAAP the consignor keeps control and the goods stay on the consignor's balance sheet until control transfers, which usually means until the piece sells to an end customer. If you are carrying memo-in goods inside your stock valuation, your inventory is overstated, and every number you calculate from it — turn, GMROI, borrowing base, insurance schedule — is wrong in the same direction.
This is the least glamorous problem in memo and one of the most consequential, because it corrupts the numbers you use to make buying decisions.
The rule, and where it comes from
The accounting treatment is not ambiguous. PwC's revenue guidance states that the manufacturer or consignor retains control and ownership, and goods remain on the manufacturer's balance sheet until control transfers.
On timing, the same guidance is direct: revenue is not recognised upon delivery of a product if the product is held on consignment. Recognition occurs when the product sells to a final customer, when a specified period expires, or when the goods are lost or damaged — that is, when the reporting entity has transferred control of the goods to the distributor.
ASC 606-10-55-80 sets out the indicators that an arrangement is a consignment:
- The product is controlled by the entity until a specified event occurs, such as the sale of the product to a customer of the dealer, or until a specified period expires.
- The entity is able to require the return of the product or transfer the product to a third party, such as another dealer.
- The dealer does not have an unconditional obligation to pay for the product, although it might be required to pay a deposit.
Read against a typical jewelry memo, all three usually hold. The supplier can call the parcel back. The retailer owes nothing unless and until the piece sells. The arrangement is a consignment whether or not anyone involved uses that word.
The trap: possession is not control
The most useful practical point in PwC's guidance is a warning aimed at consignors rather than consignees: a manufacturer should assess whether its retained rights are actually enforceable, because physical possession alone does not indicate control.
That cuts both ways in this trade.
If you are a supplier whose memo terms exist on paper but are never enforced — goods stay out indefinitely, returns are never called, nobody reconciles — you may have a harder argument that you retained control than your paperwork suggests. Consignment accounting depends on rights that are real, not rights that are merely printed.
And if you are a retailer treating memo goods as effectively yours because in practice nobody ever asks for them back, the informality is not neutral. It affects the accounting characterisation, and it sits uncomfortably beside the legal position, where most memo arrangements are consignments under UCC Article 9 and the merchant is deemed to have the same rights in the goods as the consignor while it holds them. That analysis is here.
What breaks when memo goods are counted as stock
This is where an accounting technicality becomes an operating problem.
Inventory turn is understated. Turn by cost is cost of goods sold divided by inventory on hand. Inflate the denominator with goods you do not own and your turn drops. Given that the average yearly inventory turn for an American retail jewelry store sits somewhere in the 0.7 to 1.2 range to begin with, a distortion of that size is not a rounding error — it is the difference between a store that looks like it is performing and one that does not. More on turn here.
GMROI is understated. GMROI is gross profit dollars divided by inventory at cost. Same denominator, same distortion. Abe Sherman's benchmark for the trade is a GMROI of at least $1.00 and not much more than $1.50, against an industry average he has put in the $0.70 to $0.75 range. If part of your denominator is somebody else's goods, you cannot tell where you actually sit against that. More on GMROI here.
Aged inventory analysis is polluted. Aged stock is one of the sharpest diagnostics in jewelry retail, and the targets are specific — Dick Abbott of The Edge has put the target for aged stock at 20 percent of total inventory, while JCK has reported that in many stores over half the total inventory being offered to customers is aged. Mixing consigned goods into that calculation makes the number meaningless, and the aged analysis is one you actually want to act on. More here.
Your borrowing base may be wrong. If you borrow against inventory, pledging goods you do not own is a problem in its own right — and one that becomes acute precisely when the lender starts looking closely.
Your insurance may be misaligned in both directions. Owned inventory and goods held on memo are covered differently. A policy covering your owned inventory does not automatically extend to someone else's inventory sitting in the same case; a jewelers block policy is the product that explicitly covers memo, consignment and customers' goods. A single blended stock figure tells you nothing about whether you are covered for the right things.
What the supplier side has to get right
The mirror-image discipline is just as important, and it is mostly about timing.
Goods out on memo stay on your balance sheet. That is correct, but it means the asset is real, outside your control, and generating nothing until it sells. That is the whole economic argument for aging memo tightly rather than letting it drift.
Revenue is recognised when the piece sells to the end customer, which means you need the retailer to actually report the sale. This is why the trade's recommended payment terms are 15 to 30 days from sale and why JVC's guidance builds monthly reconciliation into the agreement as an obligation. A sale that happens and is not reported is not just a cash-flow delay; it is a period in which your books and reality disagree.
And if the goods are lost or damaged while out, control has transferred for revenue purposes — which is another reason the insurance and loss-payee clauses in the memo agreement matter beyond the obvious.
The practical version
Three things will keep this straight in most businesses.
Flag ownership at the item level, not the report level. Every piece in the building should be identifiable as owned or consigned, and whose it is if consigned. JVC's guidance already calls for segregated, tagged inventory so goods remain identifiable — the accounting benefit is a second reason to do it.
Run two stock values, always. Owned inventory at cost is the number that goes into turn, GMROI and any conversation with a lender. Goods held on memo is a separate figure that goes into your insurance and your supplier reconciliations. Never blend them into one headline number, because the headline number is the one people quote.
Give your accountant the detail. Not a total, but which goods, whose, on what terms, and what has sold and not yet been settled. That distinction is not one they can reconstruct from a single inventory figure.
One honest note on sourcing: the treatment of cost of goods sold on consignment follows logically from the revenue guidance, but the explicit COGS timing is not something we can point at a free authoritative source for. Your accountant can, and it is worth asking rather than inferring.
Where Jewelia fits
The reason memo goods end up in stock valuations is almost always that the system had nowhere else to put them. Memo & Ledger keeps memo in as its own record rather than as inventory: what you hold, from whom, on what terms, what is due back, what has sold and what you owe. Owned stock lives in inventory with its own valuation — cost and retail per item, plus a replacement valuation at today's metal spot prices for when the insurer asks — so the two numbers stay separate by construction rather than by discipline.
Every memo line carries its own status, so goods that have sold are distinguishable from goods still out, which is what makes the revenue-recognition question answerable rather than estimated. A sold line converts to an invoice in one click. And the reporting calculates inventory value on owned stock, so turn and valuation figures are not quietly inflated by somebody else's parcels.
Memo out and the Ledger are on the $179 Starter plan; memo in is on Professional.
Bottom line
Goods on memo sit in your case and on somebody else's balance sheet. Keep them out of your stock valuation, keep them inside your insurance, tag them so the distinction survives contact with a busy Saturday, and run two stock numbers rather than one. Otherwise the ratios you use to decide what to buy next are built on inventory you do not own.
This article describes general US GAAP principles and is not accounting advice. Talk to your accountant about your own arrangements.
Frequently asked questions
- Do consigned goods count as my inventory?
- No. Under US GAAP the consignor retains control of goods held on consignment, and they remain on the consignor's balance sheet until control transfers. If you are the retailer holding goods on memo, they are not your inventory and should not appear in your stock valuation.
- When is revenue recognised on consigned goods?
- Not on delivery. PwC's guidance is explicit that revenue is not recognised upon delivery of a product if the product is held on consignment. Recognition happens when control transfers — typically when the product sells to an end customer, when a specified period expires, or when the goods are lost or damaged.
- What are the indicators that an arrangement is a consignment?
- ASC 606-10-55-80 lists them: the product is controlled by the entity until a specified event occurs, such as sale to a customer of the dealer or the expiry of a specified period; the entity can require the return of the product or transfer it to a third party; and the dealer does not have an unconditional obligation to pay for the product, although it might be required to pay a deposit.
- Does having the goods in my case mean I control them?
- No, and this is the point auditors press on. Physical possession alone does not indicate control. PwC's practice warning runs the other way too: a consignor should assess whether its retained rights are actually enforceable, because a memo agreement nobody enforces may not support consignment accounting.
- What breaks if I count memo goods as stock?
- Your inventory value is overstated, which means every ratio built on it is wrong. Inventory turn looks worse than reality because the denominator is inflated. GMROI looks worse for the same reason. Your insurance schedule may be misaligned. And if you borrow against inventory, you may be pledging goods you do not own.
- Should I tell my accountant which stock is on memo?
- Yes, and give them the detail rather than a total. Which goods, whose they are, what terms they are on, and what has sold but not yet been reported or settled. The distinction between owned and consigned stock is one your accountant cannot make from a single inventory figure.
Stop reading, start clicking.
Open a live Jewelia company with real inventory, memo, jobs and reports already in it. One work email, no card, no sales call, nothing to install.




