Short answer: a jewelry memo agreement should do six things — retain title in you, set payment terms at 15 to 30 days from sale, define when and in what condition goods come back, put insurance in place naming you as loss payee before delivery, require the goods to stay segregated and identifiable, and oblige the merchant to tell you if its address or legal name changes. Most memo paperwork in circulation does one or two of those. The rest is left implied, and implied terms are exactly what fail when something goes wrong.
The difference between a slip and an agreement
Almost every supplier has a memo slip: a document listing items, prices and a date, signed on delivery. Far fewer have a signed consignment agreement sitting behind it.
The distinction matters because the two documents answer different questions. The slip answers what went out. The agreement answers on what terms. When a parcel is lost, when a retailer fails, or when a piece comes back that is not the piece that went out, every question that arises is a terms question.
The Jewelers Vigilance Committee's Essential Guide to Memo Transactions is explicit that a signed consignment agreement is required, and it is the best free starting point published by anyone in the trade. What follows tracks its guidance, with the case law that shows why each clause earns its place.
The six clauses that do the work
1. Title retention, stated explicitly
The agreement must say, in terms, that the goods remain your property until paid for, and that the merchant acquires no right or authority to sell, pledge, hypothecate or otherwise dispose of them outside the ordinary course contemplated by the agreement.
This is not boilerplate. In Zaretsky v. William Goldberg Diamond Corp, a 7.44-carat diamond was consigned under an agreement containing exactly that language. The holder stole it and it passed through intermediaries to good-faith purchasers. The Second Circuit held the consignor kept ownership. In Blue River Gems Inc. v. S.V. & V. Diamond Corp, a $400,000 necklace went out under a memo stating it remained the property of the consignor with no authority to sell or dispose; when the consignee handed it to another dealer in partial satisfaction of a debt, the court granted summary judgment for the consignor on conversion.
Sara Yood of JVC gives the same advice prospectively: make sure any consignment agreements are crystal clear as to the designer maintaining title and ownership to the pieces placed on consignment.
2. Payment terms of 15 to 30 days
The trade's own recommendation, echoed by JVC and by Rapaport's reporting, is payment within 15 to 30 days of sale. JVC's guidance is to avoid lengthy payment terms.
The reason is not impatience. The longer the gap between sale and payment, the more of your capital sits inside someone else's business at the moment their business is most likely to be under strain — and the larger the sum that a preference action could later claw back if they fail.
3. Return timeframe and condition
Specify when unsold goods come back and in what state. Vague return windows are how a short-term loose-diamond consignment becomes an eighteen-month one, and how a piece comes back polished, worn, or with a stone that does not match the one that left.
Worth building in a right to call goods back on demand rather than only at the end of a term. Rapaport's reporting on retail practice describes vendors calling after a few days for status on loose diamonds, with holding periods shortening as vendors tighten up; that only works if the agreement supports it.
4. Insurance, with you as loss payee
This is the clause most often missing. JVC's guidance is that the supplier should arrange insurance naming the supplier or consignor as loss payee, to protect against loss, theft or damage, and that it should be in place before delivery.
The underlying problem is that both parties can genuinely hold an insurable interest in the same piece at the same time, in different ways — the vendor owns it, the retailer has custody and potential liability. A policy that covers your owned inventory does not automatically cover someone else's inventory sitting in the same case. A jewelers block policy is the product that explicitly extends to memo, consignment and customers' goods, but you should not assume your counterparty carries one.
The clause should say when responsibility transfers, whether the retailer must carry specific coverage, whether your own policy continues to apply, what security and storage conditions are required, and what documentation a claim will need. Rapaport adds a point worth building in: insured values should rise with metal and diamond prices over the consignment period, because exposure scales with the asset.
5. Identification: segregated, tagged, stamped
JVC's guidance covers segregated and tagged inventory so goods remain identifiable, and trademark stamping for product recognition. This does two jobs at once. It supports a claim that specific goods are yours rather than fungible stock, and it defends against substitution.
Substitution is a documented failure mode, not a hypothetical. Rapaport has reported the pattern directly: it is far too common for a supplier to provide a million-dollar diamond in exchange for a credit memo, only to find that the merchant returns a fake stone or a substituted stone worth far less. Dan Coleman of T&M Protection Resources describes GIA certification and tagging as integral measures to prevent fraud and ensure the safe return of diamonds. Donna G. Recant's framing is the one to remember when deciding whether certification is worth the cost on a given stone: without any way to prove the authenticity of the diamond provided to the merchant, the supplier's avenues for recourse will be severely limited.
6. Notification of changes, and monthly reconciliation
Two housekeeping clauses that punch above their weight.
Require the merchant to notify you of any change of legal name, registered address or entity structure. Any of those can invalidate a UCC-1 financing statement filed against them, which is how a supplier who did everything right in year one finds themselves unperfected in year three. (On why the filing matters at all, see memo and the UCC.)
And build monthly reconciliation into the agreement as an obligation rather than a favour. A reconciliation nobody has agreed to is a reconciliation that happens only when someone is already worried.
What the agreement cannot do
An agreement governs the relationship between you and the merchant. It does not, on its own, govern the relationship between you and the merchant's creditors.
Most jewelry memo arrangements are consignments under UCC Article 9, which means the merchant is deemed to have the same rights and title to the goods as you do while they are in its possession. If your interest is unperfected, the goods become part of the bankruptcy estate if the retailer fails, and you are a general unsecured creditor. Perfection means filing a UCC-1 before delivery, in the state of incorporation, against the exact legal name, with notice to any prior inventory secured party. That is a separate step from drafting a good agreement, and neither substitutes for the other.
Where Jewelia fits
The best-drafted agreement in the trade is worth very little if you cannot evidence what actually happened under it. Memo & Ledger is the operational half: every memo goes out with its terms, due date and a PDF document both sides receive, and every line is tracked independently — still out, returned, or sold at the price it actually went for — with 30/60/90 aging and an overdue count per counterparty.
Two features map directly onto clauses above. Delivery is confirmed by a link the other side opens without creating an account, ticking off line by line what actually arrived and attaching photos, so a discrepancy is logged against the memo at the moment it is discovered rather than argued about months later. And both parties can open the same netted ledger, which turns the monthly reconciliation clause from an obligation nobody honours into a shared screen. Item records carry the metal, stone and certificate detail through inventory, including GIA lookup by report number, so what went out is documented to the standard a substitution dispute would demand.
Memo out and the Ledger are on the $179 Starter plan; memo in is on Professional.
Bottom line
A memo slip records a delivery. An agreement records the terms, and the terms are what get argued about. Retain title in writing, pay in 15 to 30 days, define the return, insure with yourself as loss payee before the goods move, keep the goods identifiable, and require notice of any change that could break a filing. Then have a lawyer who knows this trade read it, because the variations between these agreements are large and the consequences of a weak one are concentrated in exactly the moments you cannot afford them.
This article describes general US commercial practice and is not legal advice.
Frequently asked questions
- What is a jewelry memo agreement?
- It is the written contract governing goods sent to a merchant for sale, where the merchant pays only if the item sells and otherwise returns it. The Jewelers Vigilance Committee's guidance is that this should be a signed consignment agreement rather than a bare memo slip — the slip records what went out, the agreement records the terms on which it went.
- What clauses does a memo agreement need?
- At minimum: explicit title retention in the consignor, payment within 15 to 30 days of sale, a defined return timeframe and condition, an insurance obligation naming the consignor as loss payee, a requirement that goods be segregated and tagged so they stay identifiable, monthly reconciliation, and an obligation on the merchant to notify you of any change of address or legal name — because either can break a UCC-1 filing.
- Who is responsible if memo goods are lost, stolen or damaged?
- Whatever the agreement says — which is the problem, because many memo agreements say nothing. They cover price, quantity and the return window and leave risk of loss implied. Both parties can hold an insurable interest in the same piece at once: the vendor owns it, the retailer has custody. A policy covering your own inventory does not automatically extend to someone else's goods in the same case, so spell it out.
- Should a memo agreement require GIA certification or tagging?
- For significant stones, yes. Dan Coleman of T&M Protection Resources has described certification and tagging as integral measures to prevent fraud and ensure the safe return of diamonds. Former judge Donna G. Recant's point is the practical one: without a way to prove the authenticity of the stone provided, a supplier's avenues for recourse are severely limited if a substituted stone comes back.
- Is a memo slip enough on its own?
- No. A slip is a delivery record. It typically does not establish title retention, insurance obligations, payment terms or return conditions, and it is those terms that courts look at. In both Zaretsky and Blue River Gems the consignor prevailed on the strength of express language retaining title and prohibiting disposition — language that lives in an agreement, not on a slip.
- Can I just use a template I found online?
- Use one as a starting point, not a finished document. Attorney Leonard M. Weiner's warning to the trade is that there are major variations in the texts of these agreements and that they should be reviewed by an attorney familiar with these issues. State law varies, your exposure varies, and the clauses that matter most are the ones a generic template is least likely to get right for you.
Stop reading, start clicking.
Open a live Jewelia company with real inventory, memo, jobs and reports already in it. One work email, no card, no sales call, nothing to install.




