Skip to content
New featureRendrid — 3D jewelry customizerTry it live
Jewelia
Inventory, margin & retail math

Open-to-buy for jewelers: walking into the show with a number

How to calculate what you can actually spend before you get to Vegas — sizing the book from GMROI, reserving for payables and consignment, allocating a replenishment share, and writing buy specs tight enough to say no with.

Daniel Sutton 7 min read
Leather folio with a notepad and a ring on a table at a jewelry trade show — planning open-to-buy

Short answer: open-to-buy is what you can commit without exceeding the inventory your business should carry. In jewelry the practical route is to size the total book from your gross profit and a GMROI goal, subtract what you already own, subtract what you are already committed to, then allocate at least a quarter of what remains to proven replenishment. Do that before the show, not on the flight home.

The honest state of the published material

Worth saying up front: there is no comprehensive open-to-buy methodology published for jewelry that we could find. General retail OTB guidance exists in abundance and mostly assumes a seasonal fashion business with short product life and predictable sell-through — which is not a jeweler.

What the trade does publish is two halves of an OTB discipline that nobody has assembled into one. BIG's inventory-sizing formula gives you the ceiling. Edge Retail Academy's product-purchase-plan guidance gives you the allocation and the process. Put together, they are enough.

And on trade shows specifically: we went looking for published guidance on buying at JCK Las Vegas, JIS or Atlanta against a plan, and found trend commentary rather than method. That is a real gap, given that a large share of the year's commitments get made in a few days on a show floor.

Step one: size the book

Before you can know what is open, you need to know what full looks like. BIG's formula inverts GMROI to answer that:

Inventory = Revenue – (Custom Sales + Repair Sales + Special Orders) × GP% ÷ GMROI Goal

More simply: Showcase Sales × Gross Margin % ÷ GMROI Goal, which is the same as Gross Profit Dollars ÷ GMROI Goal.

The subtraction is the part people skip. Custom work, repairs and special orders produce revenue without requiring showcase stock, so leaving them in inflates the inventory the formula tells you to carry. BIG's rules of thumb, if you do not have your own split: around 10 percent of revenue for repair sales, 10 percent for custom, 20 percent for all special orders.

On the GMROI goal, their recommendation is to start at $1.00. Their stated target range is $1.00 to $1.50, against an industry average they put nearer $0.70 to $0.75. Note the direction of the lever: a higher goal produces a lower permitted inventory, because you are demanding more gross profit per dollar invested. The full GMROI piece is here.

Worked through. A store doing $2 million in revenue, with 10 percent repair, 10 percent custom and 20 percent special orders, has $1.2 million in showcase sales. At 50 percent gross margin that is $600,000 of gross profit. At a $1.00 goal, the book should be $600,000 at cost.

Step two: subtract what is already spoken for

Open-to-buy is the ceiling minus reality, and reality has three parts.

What you already own, at cost, excluding goods held on memo — those are not your inventory and do not consume your budget. If the store above holds $700,000 at cost, it is already $100,000 over the number, and open-to-buy is negative before anyone opens a catalogue.

Pending accounts payable. Edge Retail Academy's guidance is to reserve funds for pending A/P before computing net OTB. Money already promised is not available.

Consignment commitments. Same treatment. Goods you have agreed to take, even if they have not arrived, are a claim on the budget.

What survives all three subtractions is the number you take to the show.

Step three: allocate before you shop

A single pooled number is too easy to spend in one booth. Two allocations turn it into a plan.

By classification. Break OTB down by category and price point, informed by where GMROI and turn say you are thin. BIG's category data shows why store-wide allocation fails — diamond studs at 2.16 turns against semi-mounts at 0.76 in the same store, with price points inside categories running 0.32 to 3.31. Money should follow that distribution, not habit.

By replenishment share. Edge Retail Academy is specific here: "With your OTB by classification, make sure that you allocate a percentage to replenishment. It should be at least 25%, but could be as much as 50%."

That second one is the discipline most often abandoned on a show floor, because replenishment is boring and new product is exciting. But replenishing a proven seller is a lower-risk use of the same dollar than betting it on something untested. Their broader advice is to lean on proven bestsellers rather than all-new product.

Step four: write specs tight enough to refuse with

Edge Retail Academy's process before buying is short: review your aged inventory, review your top sellers, then write buy specs at high specificity.

Their example of what specific means: "Semi-mounts in platinum, with round pave melee, three-quarter carat princess head, with a cost of $1,200 to $1,500."

That is the level that does work on a show floor, because it lets you say no. "Some nice semi-mounts" is not a spec; it is an appetite, and appetites get filled by whoever is most persuasive. A spec with metal, stone configuration, head size and a cost range attached gives you a defensible reason to walk past three booths.

Reviewing aged inventory first is the other half of that discipline. Walking a show having just looked at what did not sell last year is a materially different experience from walking it having not.

The show-floor rules nobody published

Since the trade has not published a show buying discipline, here is what the general OTB logic implies. Treat it as reasoning rather than as sourced guidance.

Take a written number per classification and hold it. The plan's only function is to be binding.

Count commitments at the moment you make them. Not on the flight home. A running tally per category is the whole mechanism.

Treat "show special" as a reason to check the spec, not to skip it. A discount on something outside the plan is still money leaving the plan.

Reserve a deliberate exploration budget. A named percentage for genuinely new things, so discovery is planned rather than smuggled in. Without it, discipline collapses at the first exciting booth.

Write down why you bought each thing. Six months later, when you are reviewing what worked, the reasoning is worth more than the invoice.

Why this matters more than it sounds

Open-to-buy is unglamorous, and skipping it feels harmless because the consequence is deferred by a year.

But the consequence is well documented. BIG's case studies describe stores where on-hand inventory rose $400,000 to $850,000 over three years while cost of goods sold declined. Aged stock in some stores runs past 50 percent against a trade target around 20 percent. And Geller's claim is that aged inventory shows up almost dollar for dollar with accounts payable, credit card debt and bank loans.

Those outcomes are not separate problems. They are the compounded result of buying without a ceiling. Open-to-buy is the point in the cycle where they are cheapest to prevent.

Where Jewelia fits

Every input this exercise needs already exists in your records; the difficulty is assembling it into one view at the moment you need it.

Analytics carries more than 40 built-in reports across nine categories, including sales by period and category, inventory value at cost and retail, inventory by location and aged inventory — so showcase sales, gross margin, current cost on hand and the aged tail are readings rather than a spreadsheet project. Inventory holds cost and retail per item across stores, safes and cases, and consigned goods sit in Memo & Ledger where they belong, so the number you subtract from the ceiling is goods you actually own. Purchase orders and vendor commitments live against the account in the CRM, which is what makes "what is already spoken for" answerable.

The practical version, though, is Jewelia AI: OTB work is mostly the same handful of questions asked in different slices, and asking them in plain English on the way to a show is a different experience from building six reports the week before.

Bottom line

Size the book from gross profit and a GMROI goal, not from instinct. Subtract what you own, what you owe and what you have committed. Allocate by classification, with at least a quarter to replenishment. Write specs specific enough to say no with. Review your aged stock before you go, not after. And take a written number onto the floor, because the plan only works if it is binding at the moment it is inconvenient.

Frequently asked questions

What is open-to-buy?
The amount you can commit to new merchandise in a period without exceeding the inventory your business should carry. In jewelry the cleanest route to it is to size the total book first — from showcase sales, gross margin and a GMROI goal — then subtract what you already own and what you are already committed to.
How do I work out how much inventory I should own?
BIG's formula inverts GMROI: showcase sales multiplied by gross margin percent, divided by your GMROI goal. Showcase sales means revenue less custom, repair and special orders, since those generate sales without requiring stock. Their rules of thumb for stripping those out are roughly 10 percent of revenue for repair, 10 percent for custom and 20 percent for special orders.
How much of open-to-buy should go to replenishment?
Edge Retail Academy's guidance is that within your OTB by classification you should allocate at least 25 percent to replenishment, and possibly as much as 50 percent. Proven bestsellers are a lower-risk use of budget than an equivalent spend on new product.
What should I subtract before I get to a spendable number?
Pending accounts payable and any consignment commitments, before computing net OTB. Money already promised is not open to buy, and at a show it is the easiest thing to forget because it is not physically in front of you.
How specific should a buy spec be?
Specific enough to say no with. Edge Retail Academy's example is the right level of detail: semi-mounts in platinum, with round pave melee, three-quarter carat princess head, with a cost of $1,200 to $1,500. A spec that loose lets anything through is not a spec.
Is there published guidance on buying at trade shows?
Very little. We looked for OTB discipline specific to JCK Las Vegas, JIS or Atlanta and found trend commentary rather than method. The general OTB approach applies, but nobody in the trade appears to have published a show-specific buying discipline — which is odd, given how much of the year's buying happens at them.
inventoryretail mathbuyingretail

Stop reading, start clicking.

Open a live Jewelia company with real inventory, memo, jobs and reports already in it. One work email, no card, no sales call, nothing to install.

← All articles

See it before you talk to anyone.

30-day money-back guarantee. Cancel any month, no setup fees.