Short answer: price repairs per job rather than per hour, on a shop rate of $100 to $125 built on five and a half productive hours rather than eight, marking up labour and materials separately. The target is at least 50 percent gross margin from the shop. And price with more confidence than feels comfortable, because repair customers are buying trust, not the cheapest number.
Repairs are bigger business than they get credit for
Repair services account for 6 to 25 percent of jewelers' business and rank as the third largest revenue category, according to JCK's reporting. One operation, Jewelry Artisans Inc., processes over 8,800 repair envelopes against $1.8 million in sales, half of it from repair. Jewel-Craft handles around 10,000 pieces weekly.
The number that should change how you think about the counter conversation is this one: nine or ten out of ten customers buy when quoted a repair price, against three or four out of ten on a sales pitch. A repair quote is the highest-converting thing most jewelers say all day, and it is routinely delivered apologetically.
The corollary, also from JCK: "If you send someone away who came to get jewelry repaired, they're not going to buy jewelry with you." Under-serving repair does not just cost the repair.
Per job, not per hour
David Geller's pricing system is the trade's default, and its central choice is to price procedures rather than time. His book contains over 7,000 prices covering specific repair operations across metals and techniques.
The logic is worth spelling out, because "we charge by the hour, it's fairer" sounds reasonable until you look at what it does. Hourly billing penalises skill: the jeweler who retips four prongs in twelve minutes earns less than the one who takes forty. Per-job pricing does the opposite — Geller notes that on retipping, efficiency can let jewelers make upward of $200 an hour against a nominal shop rate less than half that.
It also fixes the counter problem. A customer wants a number, now, before they hand over a ring. A price list gives them one.
The markup structure underneath is simple: 3× on labour and 3× on findings and materials, calculated separately then combined, with materials priced from the Stuller catalog plus a 50 percent buffer for potential stone loss or damage during the repair. That buffer is insurance against the job that goes wrong, priced into every job that does not.
Building the rate
Geller's recommended shop rate is $100 to $125 per hour, and the construction matters more than the number.
Start from base jeweler wages — he suggests $40,000 to $80,000 and up, with a recommendation of $50,000 or more plus another $10,000 for taxes and vacation. Then adjust +25 percent for inefficiency and +25 percent for employer taxes and benefits.
Then apply the productivity assumption, which is the part most shops skip: in a typical eight-hour work day, jewelers work on products for five and a half hours. Two and a half hours go to everything else. A rate built on eight billable hours is understated by roughly a third from the start.
One more adjustment at the job level: add 25 percent to all estimated repair times. Estimates run optimistic, consistently, everywhere.
A worked example from the method: a 20-minute sizing job prices at $42 in labour. National sizing prices run $20 to $85 retail.
What the bench should produce
Geller's benchmarks give you something to measure against:
- A jeweler's bench should produce $185,000 to $250,000 in sales a year
- Bench work should show almost 70 percent gross profit before salaries
- After adding the jeweler's salary plus taxes and vacation, 60 percent
- Budget roughly $1,000 a month on findings, supplies and tools
Against that, his minimum target for the shop overall is no less than a 50 percent gross profit margin, keystone; his own store achieved 63 percent.
If your bench is well below $185,000, the question to ask is which of three things is wrong: the prices, the volume, or the share of bench time spent on work that was never quoted.
What working shops actually charge
Published benchmarks are useful; real prices are more useful. Ganoksin's interviews with named jewelers give some:
Jeff Johnson (Columbus, OH) uses a $20 an hour bench wage benchmark, and makes the sharpest point in the whole piece about complimentary work: "If you pay your bench jeweler $20 an hour, you just gave away $5" — that being fifteen minutes of free polishing. Free polishing is not free; it is a discount you are not measuring.
Sara Grinnell (Minnesota) charges $169 for a crown replacement with a 0.5ct marquise in platinum, bills the laser welder at $1 per minute, and prices an earring post repair at $15 by solder against $18 by laser at three minutes. Coloured stones go supplier price, retail markup, then a 20 percent discount. On retipping: "The main cost you incur is setup" — which is exactly why per-tip rates should decrease on multiples, as Geller's schedule does.
Jon Barry Dinola (Pennsylvania) charges $75 an hour for complex work such as holloware dent removal, and $9 for a watch battery where a competitor charges $3: "I charge triple, but I can explain what I do to the customer, and that's what matters." He guarantees prong retipping for a year.
All three cite Geller's book as their foundation and then adjust for local market, credentials and equipment. That is the right pattern — a published schedule as a floor, adjusted deliberately rather than improvised per job.
Guarantees, and pricing them in
Guarantees appear throughout the well-run examples, and they are a pricing decision rather than a marketing one. Geller's schedule includes up to four stones in a check-and-tighten with a twelve-month guarantee, and adds $28 for rings with five to twenty stones. Dinola guarantees retipping for a year. JCK's example of a $125 ring sizing includes stone tightening, refinishing and a one-year guarantee.
A guarantee priced in is a differentiator. A guarantee given away is an uncosted liability.
Trust-sensitive, not price-sensitive
The phrase recurs in the literature because it keeps proving true. JCK: repairs are less price-sensitive and more trust-sensitive. Geller's estimate is that around 90 percent of customers will have you fix their items despite cheaper competitors existing.
What people are actually deciding is whether to hand a stranger something irreplaceable. Which means the things that win the job are a clear explanation, a documented intake, a specific delivery date and a guarantee — not being the cheapest sizing in town. Dinola's watch battery at triple the competitor's price works because he can explain what he does.
Two operational habits from JCK's reporting support that directly. Quote specific delivery dates, not "about a week." And at intake, describe metal by colour only — "yellow", not "gold" — noting quality stamps as stamps ("stamped 14k"), which protects you when a customer's assumption about their own piece turns out to be wrong.
Where Jewelia fits
Pricing per job only works if the job record supports it. Production & Repairs takes the repair in with the item, the fault, the quote and the promised date, with before photos attached and a barcoded tag printed at the counter — which is the documentation that makes a dispute about a pre-existing mark answerable. Materials and charges added at the bench land on the job as they happen, so the 3× on findings is applied to what was actually used rather than what someone remembers.
Mark the piece ready and the invoice raises itself with those charges already on it, which closes the single biggest leak in repair work: the job that was done and never fully billed. Clients are notified automatically at the stages you choose, which removes most of the status calls. And analytics reports turnaround and throughput by job type, so you can see which procedures are genuinely profitable and which are being subsidised by the rest of the board.
There is a page for this: Jewelia for repair and service businesses, from $179 a month for a one-person bench. The buyer's-guide version is our jewelry repair shop software guide.
Bottom line
Price per job from a published schedule, adjusted for your market. Build the shop rate on five and a half productive hours at $100 to $125, with 25 percent loaded for inefficiency and 25 for employment costs. Mark up labour and materials separately at 3×, with a 50 percent buffer on materials. Add 25 percent to every time estimate. Stop giving away polishing. And quote with confidence, because nine in ten people say yes.
Frequently asked questions
- Should I price repairs by the hour or by the job?
- By the job. David Geller's method — the trade's de facto standard — prices specific procedures rather than billing time, with over 7,000 prices across metals and techniques. Per-job pricing rewards a fast bench instead of penalising it, and it lets you quote a customer a number at the counter without guessing at hours.
- What shop rate should I use?
- Geller recommends $100 to $125 per hour, built on the assumption that in a typical eight-hour day jewelers work on products for five and a half hours. A rate calculated on eight billable hours understates cost by roughly a third before you have done anything wrong.
- What margin should repair work produce?
- Geller targets no less than a 50 percent gross profit margin from the shop and reports his own store achieving 63 percent. On bench work specifically he cites almost 70 percent gross profit before salaries, and 60 percent after adding a jeweler's salary plus taxes and vacation.
- How much should a bench jeweler produce?
- Geller's benchmark is $185,000 to $250,000 in sales a year per bench, against a recommended salary of $50,000 or more plus around $10,000 for taxes and vacation, and roughly $1,000 a month on findings, supplies and tools.
- Are repair customers price-sensitive?
- Much less than most jewelers assume. JCK reports that nine or ten out of ten customers buy when quoted a repair price, against three or four out of ten on a sales pitch. Geller's framing is that repair work is trust-sensitive rather than price-sensitive, and that around 90 percent of customers will have you fix their items despite cheaper competitors existing.
- Should I charge more when I use a laser?
- Only where the laser is genuinely required. Geller's rule is to charge 50 percent more on sizing, tipping and soldering where the laser is necessary to do the job, and no premium where it is merely faster — because there the profit already comes from the speed.
Stop reading, start clicking.
Open a live Jewelia company with real inventory, memo, jobs and reports already in it. One work email, no card, no sales call, nothing to install.




