Short answer: refining is a market where the headline number is the least informative part of the quote. What decides your actual return is the fee stack underneath it, the assay method, the settlement time and whether you get a sample of your own. Two refiners advertising similar payouts can produce materially different cheques on the same lot, and the only way to know is to run both schedules against an identical hypothetical lot before you ship.
First, the two processes — because they explain the pricing
Material arriving at a refiner splits into two paths, and almost every pricing difference follows from which path your lot takes.
Meltable, which covers trees, sprues, filings and bench sweeps, is melted, sampled and assayed.
Burnable, which covers polishing dust, floor sweeps and sludge, is incinerated, then ball milled or crushed, screened, sampled and assayed.
The burnable path is longer, dirtier and more labour-intensive, which is why sweeps settle slower and carry higher percentage fees. It also explains a detail worth money to you: charges on sweeps are associated with the incoming weight of the material. Pulling steel out with a magnet before shipping reduces the weight of the lot and lowers the refining cost. That is a five-minute job with a direct return.
The same logic explains why grading matters. Companies that refine sweeps pay higher for clean sweeps than dirty ones, as Arthur Anton Skuratowicz has put it — so the discipline of keeping clean filings separate from general sweep, described in our piece on where your gold actually goes, pays twice: once in yield, once in fees.
Two published fee schedules, side by side
Most refiners quote on request. Two publish, and both are worth reading in full before you commit a lot anywhere.
Dillon Gage's published schedule is structured by material and lot size:
- Gold: minimum lot value $10,000 in contained pure gold, silver and platinum combined. Karat scrap at 1 percent over 50 ounces, 2 percent under 50 ounces. Assay fee $30 per lot. Bench sweeps 10 to 20 percent depending on quantity. Polishing dust, 5 lb minimum, at 80 percent of bid spot under 10 lb and 90 percent over. Gold-filled, 10 lb minimum.
- Silver: minimum lot value $5,000. Over 100 ounces, 95 percent return; under 100 ounces, 90 percent. Assay fee $30. Low-grade silver under 70 percent pure, 20 percent fee. Silver flake at a $0.37 market discount to bid spot with a $30 minimum. Assay fee waived on hallmarked sterling coins and medallions.
- Platinum group: minimum lot value $5,000. Platinum 10 percent under 10 ounces, 5 percent over. Palladium 15 percent. Rhodium 20 percent.
- Stone removal: $5 per gross troy ounce with a $50 minimum; platinum $7 per gross ounce received with a $50 minimum processing fee.
Elemetal's published charges take a different shape:
- Lot fee: $1.85 flat, with no separate melt, assay or refining charge
- Stone removal: 1 percent of metal value, $30 minimum
- Four-way assay covering gold, silver, platinum and palladium: $75
- Express shipping: $14 gold, $25 silver
Notice that these two structures are not directly comparable by eye. One prices mainly as a percentage by material and size; the other prices mainly as flat fees. Which is cheaper depends entirely on your lot profile — a small, clean, high-grade lot and a large, dirty, mixed lot will rank them differently.
Settlement times, by material
This is the variable most shops forget to ask about and then resent for the next three months.
Ganoksin's guidance by material type: gold metallic scrap, straight exchange to 10 days. Gold sweeps, two weeks to four weeks. Platinum, extended out to 14 weeks regardless of material type — although some refiners settle platinum-only lots in as little as two days.
Dillon Gage publishes its own: high-grade karat scrap 24 to 48 hours from receipt, gold filings around 4 days, bench sweeps about ten business days, polishing dust 7 to 10 days, silver around 5 to 7 days, platinum group around 7 business days, stone removal 5 to 7 days. Elemetal states sweeps turnarounds are typically ten business days or less.
Fourteen weeks on platinum against two days is a working-capital difference, not a service-quality footnote. Ask before you ship.
Assay: the part that decides the number
Assay timing, per Ganoksin: gold takes two to six hours; platinum up to a full day using gravimetric or atomic absorption methods.
Method matters more than speed. Fire assay destroys the sample, takes hours, and resolves to a fraction of a part per thousand under ISO 11426:2021 — it is what LBMA Good Delivery refiners use. XRF returns a purity reading in about ten seconds but penetrates only between 5 and 50 microns, typically 10 to 20 in pure gold. On large flat items XRF agrees with fire assay to roughly 0.1 to 0.2 percent, but it is reading a surface, not a body. For a settlement, you want fire assay.
Platinum sampling has its own traps. Ganoksin advises against pin sampling, since the glass pin tube will normally melt before the sample can be taken; grain samples require timing, skill and the proper technique; the foil sample is described as the most accurate of the sample methods. Magnetic platinum alloys may require a 200 to 300 percent addition of copper to eliminate the magnetics.
The four questions
Ganoksin's checklist is the best single thing published on choosing a refiner, and it is four questions long:
- Do you get a sample for your own assay?
- Do you witness your material being processed?
- Do you get paid for your oversized material?
- What are the settlement times for your return?
A refiner comfortable answering all four is telling you something about how they operate. A refiner who deflects on the first is telling you more.
Comparing on net, not on headline
Elemetal's own framing of the core problem is unusually candid for a vendor: an advertised payout percentage — the portion of recovered precious metal value a refiner says it will return after processing — does not always reflect the amount you will actually receive.
Their recommended method is the right one:
- Request itemised, written fee schedules.
- Calculate net payout using identical hypothetical lot parameters. Same weights, same karat, same material mix, run through both schedules.
- Verify assay methods and whether processing is genuinely in-house.
- Evaluate reputation, compliance and reviews.
- Consider security, shipping options and communication.
Step two is the whole exercise. Build one spreadsheet representing a typical lot of yours and run every quote through it. It takes an afternoon once and settles the question for years.
One thing that is not published anywhere, despite being widely asked for: a standard net-weight-shipped-versus-fine-ounces-returned benchmarking ratio. No trade body publishes one. The identical-hypothetical-lot method is the closest thing the industry has, and it is better than a ratio anyway because it is yours.
Hidden charges and due diligence
The trade's own practitioners are direct about where this goes wrong. Rafael Amador of United Precious Metal Refining: "One of the biggest complaints in the industry has to do with 'hidden charges' that some refiners divulge after the lot is completed." The remedy is unromantic — get terms in writing before you ship, every time, including deleterious metal charges for cadmium or lead in silver lots.
Torry Hoover of Hoover & Strong on picking a house: "Stick with companies that have been in the business for a long time — there are several of us who have been doing this for more than 100 years." Andy Holwell of Johnson Matthey on a good sign: "If we think a lot is too small for our own process, we'll always be able to recommend someone else who we trust."
Two more practical notes. Check financial stability through the Jewelers Board of Trade before sending significant material — a refiner holding your metal is a counterparty, not just a supplier. And be aware the number of refining companies roughly tripled in four years, which means the field includes a lot of houses without a long record.
Finally, not every supplier takes every material. Garfield, PMRS, Cookson CLAL and Cooksongold accept both sweeps and clean scrap; Rio Grande, Stuller and Hoover & Strong take clean scrap only, per Metalsmith Society's comparison. Stuller waives its processing fee if you take payment in store credit. Check current terms directly — published comparisons date quickly.
Where Jewelia fits
Refining returns are only auditable if you know what went out. Production & Repairs records materials against each job as the work happens, and stage forms capture what was issued and what came back, so scrap returned to a lot can be traced to the jobs it came from rather than appearing as an unexplained bucket. Inventory carries metal type, karat, weight and fineness on every item, which is what makes a lot's expected content something you can estimate before the assay rather than accept afterwards.
Then analytics closes the loop: scrap and materials recorded per job become a rate over time, so a refining settlement that comes back light is a question you can investigate rather than a disappointment you absorb.
Bottom line
Ask the four questions. Get the schedule in writing. Build one hypothetical lot and run every quote through it, because the advertised percentage is the least informative number in the quote. Magnet the steel out before you ship. Keep clean filings away from general sweep. And ask about settlement times before you commit platinum, unless fourteen weeks of working capital is something you can shrug at.
Frequently asked questions
- What does refining actually cost?
- It depends on material and lot size, and the good refiners publish it. Dillon Gage's published schedule charges 1 percent on karat gold scrap over 50 ounces and 2 percent under, with a $30 assay fee per lot; bench sweeps at 10 to 20 percent depending on quantity; platinum at 10 percent under 10 ounces and 5 percent over; palladium 15 percent and rhodium 20 percent. Elemetal publishes a $1.85 flat lot fee with no separate melt, assay or refining charge, and a $75 four-way assay.
- How long does settlement take?
- By material. Ganoksin's guidance is straight exchange to 10 days for gold metallic scrap, two to four weeks for gold sweeps, and platinum extended out to 14 weeks regardless of material type — though some refiners settle platinum-only lots much faster. Dillon Gage publishes 24 to 48 hours for high-grade karat scrap, about ten business days for bench sweeps and 7 to 10 days for polishing dust.
- Why is the advertised payout percentage misleading?
- Because it is one number in a stack. Elemetal puts it plainly: an advertised payout percentage does not always reflect the amount you will actually receive. Lot fees, assay fees, stone removal, shipping, rush processing and minimum-lot rules all sit between the headline and the cheque.
- How should I compare two refiners?
- Elemetal's method is to request itemised written fee schedules and then calculate net payout on identical hypothetical lot parameters. Ganoksin's four questions are the other half: do you get a sample for your own assay, do you witness your material being processed, do you get paid for oversized material, and what are the settlement times.
- What is the difference between karat scrap and sweeps at the refinery?
- The process. Meltable material — trees, sprues, filings, bench sweeps — is melted, sampled and assayed. Burnable material — polishing dust, floor sweeps, sludge — is incinerated, ball milled or crushed, screened, sampled and assayed. That is why sweeps settle slower and cost more, and why fees on sweeps are charged against incoming weight.
- Is fire assay or XRF more accurate?
- Fire assay. It destroys the sample, takes hours, and resolves to a fraction of a part per thousand under ISO 11426. XRF returns a purity reading in about ten seconds but penetrates only 5 to 50 microns, so it reads the surface rather than the body of the material. For a settlement you want fire assay.
Stop reading, start clicking.
Open a live Jewelia company with real inventory, memo, jobs and reports already in it. One work email, no card, no sales call, nothing to install.




