Skip to content
New featureRendrid — 3D jewelry customizerTry it live
Jewelia
Production, orders & repairs

How to cost a piece of jewelry without guessing

A worked build-up from metal at today's price through stones, bench hours, outwork and overhead — with the trade's published premiums, hourly rates and keystone conventions, and the reason a big move in gold changes retail less than you'd think.

Daniel Sutton 7 min read
Gold, a green wax model, a raw casting, loose diamonds and the finished diamond ring — the components of jewelry job costing

Short answer: cost a piece as metal at today's price plus stones at replacement cost plus bench hours at a real rate plus outwork plus an overhead allocation — then apply your markup. The two errors that do most of the damage are costing metal at what you paid rather than what it costs now, and using an hourly rate that does not carry overhead or account for the hours a bench is not productive.

Start from a worked example

The most useful published costing in the trade is Timothy W. Green's line-by-line build-up on Ganoksin of a single piece that priced at $8,450. It is worth seeing in full because the reasoning behind each line is the transferable part.

  • Metal. 18k white gold settings, 18 dwt, charged at $120 per dwt — keystone of cost at that day's price.
  • Chain. Purchased at $425, charged at $850. Keystone.
  • Diamonds. 0.57 carats total at $1,300 per carat, which is keystone of cost.
  • Sapphires. 2 carats at $550 per carat, priced at current replacement rather than original cost.
  • Chalcedony. Cost $260, charged at $650 — a 2.5× multiple rather than the usual 2×, with the reasoning stated openly: "We normally double our costs, but we added another half percent because we knew that we got them for a bargain."
  • Labour. $2,950, at $75 per hour for both design and bench labour in gold, and $100 per hour for platinum.

Two principles do most of the work here. Materials are charged at keystone of cost at that day's price. And where the original cost is stale, replacement cost is substituted. Neither is exotic; both are routinely skipped.

The premiums that belong in cost, not margin

Metal does not arrive at spot, and if your costing pretends otherwise the difference comes straight out of your margin. Ganoksin's published premiums for 14k gold:

  • Casting grain: around 15 percent over market price
  • Contracted casting services: 18 to 20 percent premium for gold
  • Self-alloyed karat gold: 8 to 10 percent over market

Those are cost-of-goods figures. If you buy grain at a 15 percent premium and cost the piece at spot, you have handed away 15 percent of the metal content before anyone has touched it.

Labour, and the hours nobody bills

The hourly rate question is really two questions: what is the rate, and how many hours actually get billed.

On rate, the published figures span a range because they include different things. Ganoksin's costing article uses $75 per hour for design and bench labour in gold and $100 for platinum. Elsewhere it uses "$45 an hour" as a combined labour and overhead figure — a worked line reads "Labor and overhead at $45 hour, 2 hours in finishing, assembly and setting (including cleaning and packaging) = $90.00." David Geller recommends a shop rate of $100 to $125 per hour for repair work.

On hours, Geller's productivity assumption is the number worth internalising: in a typical eight-hour work day, jewelers work on products for five and a half hours. Two and a half hours a day are non-productive. A rate calculated on eight billable hours is a rate that loses money on every day it is used.

His other adjustments are in the same spirit. Build labour cost from base jeweler wages, then add 25 percent for inefficiency and 25 percent for employer taxes and benefits. And on estimating a specific job: add 25 percent to all estimated repair times as a buffer.

Overhead, which nobody wants to calculate

Ganoksin's line on this is blunt and correct: "You need to know how much it costs to operate your business, including such things as wages, taxes, rent, utilities, insurance, and everything else you pay for to operate." And, realistically: "It is not unusual for it to take a couple years in business to acquire an accurate profile of your business costs."

There is no shortcut. Either overhead lives inside a blended labour-and-overhead rate, as in the $45 example, or it is allocated separately. What it must not do is live nowhere, which is the default in most small shops.

The full build-up

Putting it together, a defensible cost for a piece has seven lines:

  1. Metal — weight × today's price, plus the acquisition premium you actually pay
  2. Metal loss allowance — from your own measured rate, if you have one
  3. Stones — at replacement cost, not historical
  4. Findings and components — at current cost
  5. Bench labour — hours × a rate built on productive hours with inefficiency and employment costs loaded
  6. Outwork — casting, setting, engraving, plating, at quoted cost
  7. Overhead — allocated, or carried inside the labour rate

Then markup. The trade convention is keystone on materials; Ganoksin's worked ring shows a wholesale cost of $263.25 taken to $315.90 with a 20 percent profit, then to $789.75 at a typical 150 percent retail markup. With casting quantity discounts the same ring runs $306.18 wholesale and $765.45 retail.

On line 2, one honest caveat. No trade source we could find publishes a casting-loss allowance to build into a job cost — the published costing examples charge metal at actual weight with no stated uplift. If you want an allowance, you have to measure your own, which is what our piece on metal loss is about.

The gold panic, in perspective

Every time metal moves sharply, shops repricing everything in a hurry is the standard response. Ganoksin's worked comparison is a useful corrective.

Taking gold from $400 to $630 an ounce and diamonds from $380 to $480 a carat raised the combined cost of the example piece by $43.79 — which produced only about a 16.5 percent increase in the retail price.

The reason is structural: on a finished piece, metal is one component among several, sitting alongside stones, labour, outwork and overhead, and the markup applies across all of them. A 50 percent move in one input does not become a 50 percent move in the price.

That cuts both ways. It means a rising market is less catastrophic than it feels. It also means that if your margin is collapsing when metal rises, the problem is probably not the metal — it is that your costing is anchored to historical prices somewhere, or that labour is under-recovered.

Simpler formulas, for smaller makers

Not every shop needs a seven-line build-up. Metalsmith Society collects formulas from working makers that are worth knowing as sanity checks:

  • Jessica Rose, simple: (Materials + Labor) × 2 + Extras = Retail Price
  • Jessica Rose, fine jewelry: (High-Cost Materials × 1.5) + (Other Materials + Labor) × 2 + Extras = Retail Price
  • All-In Small Business: Materials + $20/hr labor + 10% overhead = Wholesale, then Wholesale × 2 or 2.5 = Retail, with wholesale at 50 percent of retail

The standing advice attached to all of them is the same one running through this piece: price for replacement, not purchase, and review pricing every three to six months.

Where Jewelia fits

Costing falls apart when the inputs live in different places. Inventory carries metal type, karat, weight and fineness, and stone attributes with GIA certificate lookup, so a quote is built from real specifications rather than recalled ones — and it reports a replacement valuation at today's metal spot prices alongside cost, which is the "price for replacement, not purchase" principle made automatic.

Production & Repairs records materials drawn and time recorded against stages as the work happens, including outwork sent to a caster or setter with its own due date, so the labour and outwork lines are captured rather than estimated afterwards. The CRM builds the quote from live inventory and converts it to an invoice on the same record, and when a client changes a stone mid-job the spec, the price and the timeline update together rather than drifting apart — the failure mode described in our custom order workflow piece.

Then analytics answers the question costing exists to serve: what each kind of job actually costs you in bench time, and which ones are quietly unprofitable.

Bottom line

Cost metal and stones at today's price, not what you paid. Carry your acquisition premiums — 15 percent on casting grain, 18 to 20 on contracted casting — inside cost rather than inside margin. Build the labour rate on five and a half productive hours, not eight, with inefficiency and employment costs loaded. Allocate overhead somewhere rather than nowhere. And when gold jumps, check your costing before you reprice the case, because the arithmetic says the retail effect is smaller than the headline.

Frequently asked questions

How do jewelers price a custom piece?
The published convention is keystone — doubling — applied to metal and stones at that day's price rather than at what you originally paid, plus labour at an hourly rate. Timothy W. Green's worked example on Ganoksin charges 18k at $120 per dwt, chain purchased at $425 and charged at $850, and diamonds at keystone of cost, with labour at $75 per hour for gold and $100 per hour for platinum.
Should I cost metal at what I paid or at today's price?
Today's. The published examples charge metal and stones at keystone of cost at that day's price, and substitute current replacement pricing for historical cost where relevant. Costing off what you paid eighteen months ago is how margin quietly disappears in a rising market.
What premiums should I expect over spot?
Ganoksin's published figures for 14k gold: casting grain around 15 percent over market price, contracted casting services 18 to 20 percent, and self-alloyed karat gold 8 to 10 percent over market. Those premiums belong in the cost, not in your margin.
How much does a big move in gold actually change retail price?
Less than most people assume. Ganoksin's worked example took gold from $400 to $630 an ounce and diamonds from $380 to $480 a carat — a combined cost increase of $43.79 on the piece — and found it produced only about a 16.5 percent increase in the retail price, because metal is one component among several.
What hourly rate should I use for bench labour?
The published rates vary with what is included. Ganoksin's costing examples use $75 per hour for design and bench labour in gold and $100 for platinum, and elsewhere $45 per hour for labour and overhead combined in finishing and assembly. David Geller recommends a shop rate of $100 to $125 per hour for repair work.
Should I add a casting loss allowance to the metal weight?
If you have measured one. No trade source we could find publishes a casting-loss allowance to build into a job cost — the published costing examples charge metal at actual weight without a stated uplift. So the allowance has to come from your own measured loss rate rather than from a borrowed figure.
manufacturingcostingproductioncustom orders

Stop reading, start clicking.

Open a live Jewelia company with real inventory, memo, jobs and reports already in it. One work email, no card, no sales call, nothing to install.

← All articles

See it before you talk to anyone.

30-day money-back guarantee. Cancel any month, no setup fees.